Can you tell the difference between real and fake Democrats and Republicans?
You’re about to see 10 statements that people wrote based one of two prompts: “I’m a democrat because…” or “I’m a republican because…”.
We randomly assigned each person to one prompt or the other, so they didn’t get to choose. (We offered them a bonus if their statement sounded convincing.)
That means some of these statements are real — the person is explaining why they belong to their actual political party. Some of these statements are fake — the person is pretending to belong to the opposite political party.
real statements: Democrats claiming to be Democrats, or Republicans claiming to be Republicans.
fake statements: Democrats claiming to be Republicans, or Republicans claiming to be Democrats.
Your job is to judge whether each statement is real or fake.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a democrat because I believe in equal rights for everyone, no matter what their race is, their gender, their societal class, their nationality, their age. Our government should treat everyone the same and make sure that all people get a fair chance in life. I am a democrat because I believe in a woman's right to choose, same-sex marriage, gun control, the separation of church and state, and fair taxation. I am a democrat because I believe in climate change and the need to do something to save the environment before it's too late. I am a democrat because I believe that people from all walks of life should be welcomed to the United States with open arms. I am a democrat because my party will put the people of this country first.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Republican because…”
I am a Republican because I believe that the conservative views of Republicans are best for our country. I believe in conservative financial policies. These policies include careful spending decisions and an end to deficit spending. I believe in conservative social policies. These policies support moral behavior. This behavior is best for the well being of our country. I support the Republican party by voting for Republican candidates. The policies of these candidates are best for our country. They are conservative and will bring about positive changes in our country. I am a Republican because I see conservative policies as being best for our country.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a democrat because I believe in the right to live however you want to live, it is not in my wheelhouse to judge anyone, and I think our policies in government should reflect that. I also identify as a democrat because I believe that there are serious inequalities in this country that need to be taken care of, and only one side of the isle, the democrats, seem to actually care about the rights of minorities, the working class, and actually fixing the systematic problems we have currently which has made this inequality so glaringly obvious to everyone in the first place.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Republican because…”
I am a Republican because I believe in the Free Market Enterprise and don't want the government involved in my business or financial life. We want to get the freedom and liberty to do the business in this country without any type of socialism or government bureaucracy telling us what we should do. Therefore we want lower taxes and we don't want to be over-taxed just because the other want socialized medicine and socialized programs. Finally we don't want excessive regulations and protectionism that so much damages the country, because we depend on trade from other countries in order to strengthen our economy.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a DEMOCRAT because I believe in moving with the time and not staying in one place. Things and people need to change with times and move with everyone instead of being only looking in one direction. Also I look to them for bettering the USA and making everything better, along with moving with times and looking toward bettering our country and moving forward instead of keep looking back at what happened. Look toward the future and how movements are going to look for the best of everyone in the world, not just the country and move to what is right.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Republican because…”
I am a republican because I believe we must put our country before our selfish needs. I believe that we should spend whatever needs to be spent in order to defend our nation. Income inequality might be inconvenient for some people, but it is the way our country thrives. If everyone made the same amount of money, nobody would work, leading to a hit to our economy. I believe I should have the right to defend and protect my own family with a firearm. No politician should be able to tell me, “ no you can not protect your daughter”.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a democrat because it is the party of the working class citizen, not the party of the greedy corporate fat cats. Unlike the republicans, who don't want to treat anyone else but themselves as so much as an actual human being, the democrat party actually cares about something more than themselves. We care about the social justice of the working class citizen. We care about the environment and don't believe in raping and pillaging it for our own gain at the expense of the planet. We believe in a fair living wage. We don't believe that if you're poor then you should just die because you can't afford healthcare. We don't believe that your gender should have any role to play in how well you are compensated at your job. We believe in more than a bottom line. We believe in people.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Republican because…”
I am a republican because I do not agree with the Democrats on handling the crisis at the border. The Democrats would want to give free healthcare to those who are not citizen of this country and that is something I cannot seem to wrap my head around. Why would we take resources away from those that we born here, or came here legally through the correct process, and give it to those who should not be here. It takes away from American citizens and will make it harder to get the care you need if this comes to pass. Another issue with the Democrats I have is that they do not want to question people on the 2019 census and ask if they are a US Citizen or not. That to me is just absurd since we need to take count of American citizens and not having that question on there, in my mind, takes away from the whole point of the US Census.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a Democrat because I feel it is important to actively support a major political party. In the United States, almost all elections are won by either a Republican or a Democrat. Therefore it makes no sense to register with any other political party. Indeed, doing so could deny me the right to vote in primary elections. Some states do have an open primary system, but I live in Florida, and here if you are not registered with one of the major political parties you wouldn't be able to vote until the general election. For this reason, I am a Democrat.
The following statement was written based on the prompt: “I’m a Democrat because…”
I am a Democrat because I believe in equality of opportunity for all people, regardless of background or circumstances. I believe in actively pursuing the health and well-being of all members of our society, and ultimately the world, through the spread of health care, education, equal rights, a clean environment, and fair and equitable financial systems. I think that going forward we have new and unprecedented challenges for our country and the world, and it will be Democratic ideas that solve them. Republicans are thought to bring about good economic conditions, but even there the economy is better under Democratic Presidents. Our individual outcomes are far better when the combined resources of the world are used for the betterment of all. I think that is what Democratic policies try to do and that's what I personally believe in.
Before we show you your results, we have a few more questions for you that are for informational purposes only.
By submitting, you agree to the processing of the data above for further research means. See our Privacy Policy for more info